Dissecting the 3 Stages of a Bear Market

Posted on 5/19/2022

By Jon Robinson, Portfolio Manager, ClearShares OCIO ETF

In a blog last month, I discussed how the virtually uninterrupted bull market in equities during the last 10+ years has watered down the idea of “downside protection.” This is a problem, especially since not all declines are created equal.

It has become apparent to me that a more nuanced definition of downside protection is needed, one that recognizes three distinct stages of market declines. I provided an overview of those categories in last month’s blog, and in this follow-up post I’ll round out the definitions of each stage and highlight how the systematic investing process used by Blueprint Investment Partners to sub-advise the ClearShares OCIO ETF responds.

This following visual, which I also shared in the last blog, helps to put the three stages into context by showing how each maps to the most recent major market drawdown:

Anatomy of a Bear Market

Source: ICE and Blueprint Investment Partners, 7/2/2007 to 3/31/2009

Stage 1: Reversion to the Mean (Little Action Required)

For a decline to occur, it must start from a peak.

Some peaks arrive after long expansions from the previous high. Others may be only a few basis points above a previous high. Either way, a decline from the peak represents the giving back of some or all value that was created. New highs necessarily means a return above the recent average, so a decline back to that average is to be expected over the long-term.

In fact, when looking at the S&P 500 over the last 30 years, the average distance between an all-time high and the 200-day average close is a little more than 8%. Further, the compound annual growth rate of the 200-day average for the same period is more than 8%. Taken together, the average price of stocks alone is enough to meet most investors’ financial goals, and hence a decline to the average simply means a pause from above-average returns.

The severity of a stage 1 decline can vary depending on how far prices have advanced above average, but historically these declines as high as 15% and as low as 3%. For simplicity, let us consider stage 1 to reflect the first 10% decline from a market peak.

It is our opinion, reversions to the mean are natural and even good for the long-term health of markets. After all, if NBA player Stephen Curry – who normally converts 3-point attempts at a rate of a 43% – suddenly goes on a run where he hits at 60%, then returns to a more “normal” 43%, the coach should not fret or bench him. It simply means that he has returned to average after a period of above-average performance.

Returns to the mean should be expected periodically.

The systematic investing process used to manage OCIO ETF is designed to mostly ignore stage 1 declines. In other words, we do not consider these declines to be material drawdowns that require meaningful downside protection. While sometimes emotionally tempting, overreacting to these by looking to exit the market brings with it the high likelihood that one will not fully capitalize on favorable trends in equities, which has far worse impacts to compounding than sitting through a measly 10% decline. In addition, reallocating during a stage 1 decline frequently creates short-term capital gains, which can further penalize long-term after-tax performance.

Stage 1: Reversion to the Mean

Stage 2: Below Average Returns (Point of Maximum Opportunity for Action)

Whereas stage 1 declines are normal, should be expected, and often can be ignored (sometimes they even should be celebrated), that’s not so with stage 2. In almost all client portfolios, stage 2 declines represent the earliest point where financial advisors should be on guard and “downside protection” should begin.

This is where careful timing and disciplined decision-making can have long-term consequences on compounding and the achievement of client goals.

Research conducted by the Blueprint Investment Partners team indicates that volatility and declines typically accelerate and cluster from here, so if a portfolio can be reallocated in a disciplined and repeatable way, then it can usually consistently capture the bulk of upside opportunity while smoothing out the downside risk.

For the purposes of this blog, we consider this stage to be the next 10% in decline from an all-time high. Thus, we are talking about drawdowns in the 10-20% range.

OCIO ETF is designed to execute in this stage. The portfolio is reallocated using two timeframe systems, and the rules for the most reactive system (the intermediate-term timeframe) is meant to take action at the top of this stage. Conversely, the longer-term system typically reacts closer to the middle and bottom of this stage. Segmenting the portfolio’s rules into two timeframes allows us to smooth entries and exits.

Our goal is to finish making adjustments in this stage so we avoid the truly devastating impacts of stage 3.

Stage 2: Below Average Returns

Stage 3: The Compounding Killer (Protect Capital by Being Out of the Market)

If stage 2 is the first meaningful environment for protecting downside, then stage 3 represents where the real damage to portfolios can occur in a portfolio that’s lacking risk management. At this stage, “downside protection” should already be fully engaged, in our view.

We consider this to be declines of 20% or more from a previous peak, which coincidentally is the mainstream definition of a bear market.

Our goal, depending on how fast the decline occurs, is to be defensively postured in a market that has fallen past 20-25%. Once that drop has occurred and the averages begin to stabilize, we may quickly re-enter, but we want to have already exited once it reaches stage 3.

Research conducted by the Blueprint Investment Partners team shows that stage 3 declines are like being out after midnight…nothing good happens. Sure, one can step in and get lucky enough to catch a bottom, but more times than not this ends badly. Plus, this stage is when the flight response can kick in for many clients and, without a disciplined plan to re-enter, where their compounding can be permanently impaired.

Stage 3 is potentially the largest of the three; whereas the others are 10-15% bands, in theory a stage 3 decline could go to -100%. Few investors have the conviction to stick with an investment once it has fallen more than 50%, assuming it is a meaningful portion of the portfolio. The data tells us that the flight response is extremely damaging, and yet predictable.

Stage 3: The Compounding Killer

Bringing It All Together

Hopefully the exercise of segmenting declines into their three stages has provided some perspective on when advisors and their clients should be on alert and when they shouldn’t. It is also my wish that this has provided some context on what we mean by “downside protection” for OCIO ETF. Advisors expecting us to act in stage 1 have misunderstood what our research has concluded and how our process works. Stage 2 is where the magic happens, so that by stage 3 we are wrapping up any actions or have already completed them well in advance.

If all this sounds simple, it’s because it is designed to be that way. Simple rules are hard enough to execute consistently. It’s like the five ascending levels of intellect Einstein talked about: smart, intelligent, brilliant, genius, and final – simple.


Past performance is not indicative of future results. The material above has been provided for informational purposes only and is not intended as legal or investment advice or a recommendation of any particular security or strategy. The investment strategy and themes discussed herein may be unsuitable for investors depending on their specific investment objectives and financial situation.

Opinions expressed in this commentary reflect subjective judgments of the author based on conditions at the time of writing and are subject to change without notice.

No part of this material may be reproduced in any form, or referred to in any other publication, without express written permission from Blueprint.

An index is an unmanaged portfolio of specific securities, the performance of which is often used as a benchmark in judging the relative performance of certain asset classes. Investors cannot invest directly in an index. An index does not charge management fees or brokerage expenses, and no such fees or expenses were deducted from the performance shown.

The S&P 500 Index is a market-capitalization-weighted index of the 500 largest U.S. publicly traded companies.

A basis point is one hundredth of one percent.

We use cookies to improve your experience and to help us understand how you use our site. Please refer to our cookie notice and privacy policy for more information regarding cookies and other third-party tracking that may be enabled.

Before investing you should carefully consider the Fund's investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses. This and other information is in the prospectus, a copy of which may be obtained by clicking here for OCIO, OPER, and PIFI. Please read the prospectus carefully before you invest.

Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal.

The ClearShares OCIO, OPER, and PIFI ETFs are distributed by Quasar Distributors, LLC.

Blueprint Investment Partners is an investment adviser registered under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940. Registration as an investment adviser does not imply any level of skill or training. The oral and written communications of an adviser provide you with information about which you determine to hire or retain an adviser. For more information please visit adviserinfo.sec.gov and search for our firm name.

© 2022 ClearShares

Created with
Mailchimp Freddie Badge